Where clients get caught out
Deadlock is not only a problem between partners. If the company does not approve and file its accounts, its registry sheet is closed; if there is a cause for dissolution and the director does not act within two months, they may become personally liable for later debts.
Why deadlock happens
Most SLs decide by simple majority. With two partners at 50% who disagree, there is no majority for anything: accounts, appointments, dividends or the sale of the business.
The possible solutions
- Buy-out: one partner buys the other's shares, ideally at an independently valued price.
- Sale of the business to a third party and distribution of the price.
- Mediation to reach an agreement on management or exit.
- Dissolution for paralysis, requested from the court if there is no other way; see dissolution and liquidation.
How to prevent it
A shareholders' agreement with a deadlock clause (mediator, shotgun or forced sale) solves the problem before it arises. Our shareholder disputes lawyers negotiate exits and act in court when needed.
Castell.law is the English and German-speaking practice of Castell Abogados, a law firm in Palma de Mallorca. This page is general information, not advice on a specific case: laws and procedures change, so check your situation with us before acting.
Not sure where you stand? Ask before you sign
Tell us about your matter or send us the documents you have. A lawyer will explain the risks, the options and the cost before you commit to anything.
Questions about 50/50 shareholder deadlock
What happens if two 50% partners cannot agree?
The company cannot pass resolutions, which is a legal cause for dissolution unless they find a solution.
Can one partner force the other to sell?
Not without a clause in the shareholders' agreement or bylaws; otherwise a negotiated buy-out or dissolution is needed.
Does the deadlock affect the director?
Yes: if there is a cause for dissolution and they do not act in time, they may answer for later debts.